19 July 2014

Is it over yet?


Alison Baden-Clay is dead. A white, middle aged woman of middle wealth and attractiveness is dead. Her womanising husband this week was found guilty of her murder. This shit happens every day, yet the media saturation of this woman is as suspicious as the crime itself. Why does she mean so much to us, no let me rephrase that, why does she mean so much to the media? She was white, she was moderately wealthy, she was wholesome looking housewife in middle Australia and now she is dead. Nothing much there to be honest but if the press coverage of this case is anything to go by, this murder is the most reported event in Australian history. Yet what do we have? An unfaithful dull real estate husband in debt, a woman struggling with mental health and three little girls that lost everything overnight. To be honest that doesn’t intrigue me but what does is the case or lack thereof. Instead of reporting about the fact that the case had zero evidence or the fact that the biggest murder trial in recent history doesn’t even have any evidence to suggest that she was in fact murdered or let alone by whom, the media has taken this very, very personally. Certainly members of the media, namely female journalists, have made it their mission to report every sordid detail about the lives of this people despite anyone giving two hoots. I can tell you Australian media, the word around the water bubblers are disbelief, amazement, annoyance and bewilderment and these emotions are not directed at the convicted murderer in this case. Why are we meant to care so much about this case? Why must our thin papers have 24 page spreads, including lift outs, celebrating and demonising the players in this tragedy? Did I miss something? Do I not realise the importance of these people? Why does this case mean more than the other crimes that have played out in this country’s history? Yet some people have go nuts over this case. Parking lots have been created around where her body was found, the colour yellow has been dedicated to her alone, and a day has even been set aside to celebrate her life each year. Now I am not ignorant of the devastation that murder can bring, my family has been through our fair share of these sorts of crimes. I know personally how life changing this terrible crime is, yet I struggle to understand why some murders are weighed more heavily than others. Was Alison life more important than others that have been killed? Was Gerard more terrible than other husband that killed their wife? According to the media they are and this is what is the most shocking and upsetting part of this whole sordid affair. The media made this the biggest crime or at least the most reported crime in Australian history and this why there was a parking lot erected on the site where her body was found, this is why there was commemorative poster of Alison in the paper earlier this week. The media has once again made the news and we as the consumer have been shamed into giving a damn. I am sorry media but I don’t give a damn. It doesn’t make me heartless and it doesn’t make me less of a person it just makes me more aware of the fact that this sad episode just adds to the tapestry of pain that makes humans who they are. I feel for them all, I want to hear about them all not just this case because you decided that it would resonate with us. You the media, become too close to this case, it become personal. You the media failed at the one thing you are required to do by become a part of the story itself. For some unknown reason you decided that this woman represented every woman out there and you couldn’t be further from the truth. Yes it is sad but this sadness is not just reserved for this woman and it isn’t your job to tell us otherwise. If you bothered to notice, if you bothered to do your job, you would see these stories everywhere. They may not have the money the Baden-Clay’s had, they may not be as appealing to look at, their children may not be blonde, their husbands may not be so unfaithful but they are there just as tragic as the ones that aren’t packaged in such a commercial way. If you are the word of people then please don’t tell the people what that word is. If this case was so personal to you then maybe you need to spend some time working out why it affected you so much, as to most of us out here in the real world, this case was simply another sad event in a world where sadness grows on trees. Be fair, be objective, be informative and stick to the facts and let the people decide who their tears will fall for and then you can call yourself a journalist.

3 comments:

  1. I stumbled across this blog and must say I am deeply concerned about the writer and their check on reality. Perhaps I can be a journalist in this blog and you can answer some questions. Firstly you state that the victim is a white middle aged woman and of middle wealth and attractiveness. What relevance does that have? If she was Asian or black would that have changed your opinions? Middle aged, well I guess 42 could be classified that and attractive??? Just an average looking woman in most peoples opinions Did you not pick up that part of the motive for her killing was that fact they were in debt by $1000,000. They had a property at the Gold Coast (since sold by Gerard from his prison cell for legall fees), they lived in a rental property in Brookfield, my local area, therefore not exactly 'wealthy'. She was in fact not just a woman who dedicated her life to raising her children particularly in the younger years (night feeds, nappies, toilet training) she also managed to work part time. When this terrible tragedy happened, myself along with many other local women were frightened to go out walking not knowing if this was the start of a trend. We remained vigiliant with safety until Gerard was arrested and we could be at ease.

    To be continued ...........................





































































































































































































































































































































































































































































    ReplyDelete
  2. You constantly refer to the media in a negative way. During the trial there was a criminal reporter inside the Courtroom that constantly updated verbatim what was being said in the Courtroom. There was no cameras allowed in the Courtroom at any stage during the trial. It was not until AFTER the accused was found guilty and sentenced that further information was supplied about the case from the Queensland Police Force. If it wasn't for the media relaying information we would not know as much information as we now do. I don't believe that any of that information was incorrect. The killer did not admit he killed his wife (due to his compulsive lying) and the only witness was himself. To not bother to even assist in the search of his missing wife is guilt in itself, not once did he ask the police "have you found my wife:. Even after the body was found, he didn't ask "have you found who killed my wife", why???? because he knew where he dumped the body and he already knew who killed her. The conviction was made by a Jury not members of the general public that already had an opinion of this killer. To accuse the deceased of suffering depression which in his opinion led to her demise is just disgusting!! It first started with her return from overseas having a reaction to Malaria medication, followed by Post Natal Depression (more common than people realise). Her medication was adjusted over the years but never at a high level. To then find out your husband is having an affair would have been heartbreaking but she battled on, trying to keep her marriage and her family together. It is obvious you think Gerard is innocent but going by your blog I don't think you know jack shit and have chosen not to read the twitter updates live from the Courtroom, read specialist reports etc (all of which are available to the public). You have and are entitled to your own opinion but they way you have gone about it makes me think you are cold-hearted, judgemental and dark-minded. You mentioned that this is the biggest case in Australian history - perhaps you don't watch the news! In Brisbane alone there have been some very big cases, Max Sica and the Daniel Morcombe ones come to mind. The Daniel Morcombe one has been 10 years in the making. You also mention that you know how personally life-changing something like this can be?! Then why aren't you concentrating on sympathysing with the family and friends involved? Why so bitter? Is it because you didn't get media attention and support, you felt left out, the spotlight wasn't on you???? The parking lot comment you made is an interesting one indeed! Are you aware of where the body was found? The body was found under a narrow bridge, during the investigation a 'shoulder' on the side of the road was developed for safety as there is nowhere to pull over. Hardly a parking lot at all but a spot where Allisons's family and friends can stop and look at her plaque and pay respects, a place for her children to reflect on the loving Mother they once had. You're probably also one of these people that don't think Ms McHugh was to blame in any way!!! No one has accused her of being involved in the actual murder itself but having an affair with a married man for years and the wife finding out was never going to end well and she needs to accept responsibility for being a home-wrecking slut. There may have been 24 pages in the Queensland Courier Mail but there certainly wasn't that much in other newspapers in Australia, although it did hit overseas. We are locals and passionate about community and the people in it. If you don't want to know anything, don't purchase the paper, don't watch the news and on behalf of the rest of the people who support Allison and her family, get lost, get a life and stop being so negative. Maybe you should go to University and study Journalism, maybe you could do a better job!!!!!! Yeah, right!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

    ReplyDelete
  3. I appreciate any comments and I certainly appreciate your passion but I think you misunderstood. Sometimes when things are as raw as they obviously are to you it's easy to be outraged and blinded by that. Your comments show your misunderstanding but thank you for taking the time to read it and comment.

    ReplyDelete